Skip to content

Re: GH Copilot takes

Noted by on his .


They are like workers that are hired.

Laws around “works for hire” come with their own copyright baggage that assumes workers are actual people; for instance, these laws include mechanisms by which workers can claim copyright themselves.

I’m not opposed to the general principle of training a model on copyrighted works potentially being fair use; however, the generated works would need to be sufficiently novel or seemingly “creative” by human standards for it to work. Otherwise, you’re in “derived work” territory. This, I think, is a major difference between the likes of DALL-E and Midjourney, and the likes of Copilot.

I personally found all the discourse way too hilarious, and wrote a satirical article on it only to get clobbered by Poe’s Law: An experiment to test GitHub Copilot’s legality.


Web­mentions

This site supports Webmentions, a backlink-based alternative to traditional comment forms.

Publish a response on your own website and share the link here to send me a webmention! Include a link to this page's canonical location for it to be accepted.

Webmentions received for this post appear in the following list after I approve them. I sometimes send Webmentions to myself on behalf of linking sites that don't support them. I replace broken links with Wayback Machine snapshots, if they exist.

Toggle Webmentions
by

I'm not so sure there is such a *major* difference between copilot and things like DALL-E here.Ask a powerful AI image generation model to generate "Homer Simpson eating a donut". That, and what you get is likely fairly close to prompting copilot to regurgitate a famous algorithm, with some variables renamed.It's not exactly the same, but this is a difficult area across domains.@alcinnz @humanetech

by

@Froggo @alcinnz @dctrud Enjoying all the discussions. Yes, it is complicated. Some of the discussion can be hilarious @Seirdy while all of us noobs try to ponder implications of these new revolutionary technologies. I liked the blog you have written about it, thank you.Btw, #DALLE is in beta now. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32168190Saw one comment mentioning you get full commercial usage rights, where part of this discussion is held too..https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32168318

Feel free to contact me directly with feedback; here’s my contact info